Friday Symposium
Quite a few people have asked for copies of the paper I presented at DBU last Friday. So, I decided to just post it here. Please forgive the length, and enjoy!
***************************************************
What Will I Do When I Grow Up?
Reflections of a DCM Student on the Theology of Work and Vocation
“Calling is the truth that God calls us to himself so decisively that everything we are, everything we do, and everything we have is invested with a special devotion, dynamism, and direction lived out as a response to his summons and service.”
~Os Guinness
Calling is a phenomenon that is greatly over-mystified and obscured during our times. The terms “work”, “vocation”, and “calling” are at best confused and at worst elevated to different levels of importance, ranging from necessary but mundane work, through worthy and respectable vocation, to superior and unarguable calling (that is to say, the person who receives the “call” is allowed to be dogmatic about it, regardless of how it affects those around him or her). The purpose of this paper is to define the terms work, vocation, and calling, illustrate the dynamics between them, and determine through Biblical teachings what my individual callings are.
Of the three terms, work is the easiest to define. Work is what we do when we are not at leisure. For most people, work is considered a necessary evil, and the majority of people in the work force do not enjoy what they do for a living. This is unfortunate, as well as faulty thinking and practice, for God created us as workers. This can be verified both Biblically and intrinsically.
Biblically, we cannot escape the fact that God (a worker Himself) has passed this standard to the created Adamic race. The Garden of Eden would not be considered the ultimate vacation destination by today’s standards, for Adam and Eve were designed for and commanded to work. The first commandment given to man, also referred to as the “creation mandate,” is found in Genesis 1:28: “And God blessed them, and God said unto them, Be fruitful, and multiply, and replenish the earth, and subdue it: and have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the fowl of the air, and over every living thing that moveth upon the earth.” This command is tri-fold: to populate the earth, to cultivate the earth, and to be a steward of the earth. The cultivation and stewardship aspects of the command continue in Genesis 2:15: “And the LORD God took the man, and put him into the garden of Eden to dress it and to keep it.” There is little room for ambiguity here: God physically set the man and woman into their life work. From this elevated starting point, somehow the concept of work has descended into one of drudgery and meaninglessness. Even though most people are not happy in their jobs, they would be equally unhappy in a life of complete leisure because we have an inner, God-given drive to work. There the paradox lies: it is not that people are not meant to work, but that “[j]obs are not big enough for people” (qtd. in Guinness 36). If the lives surrounding us are not enough to convince us of this, literature is full of examples of the frustrated workforce. For instance, in Tennessee Williams’ play The Glass Menagerie, Tom raves, “Look! I’d rather somebody picked up a crowbar and battered out my brains—than go back mornings! I go! […] I say to myself, ‘How lucky dead people are!’ But I get up. I go! For sixty-five dollars a month I give up all that I dream of doing and being ever!” (453). Is work really such a curse? What is the answer to this seeming paradox?
Work was an intentional part of God’s good creation, but like every other good thing created by God, work has been cursed as a result of the Fall of man. As lies are but a twisting of the truth, all sin is but a twisting or distortion, a reversal of devotion, of something that God initially intended for good. The distortion of work has brought into it the treacherous trio of futility, laziness, and idolatry (Naugle 2). Futility is the state of serving no useful purpose, according to Webster’s dictionary. As a derivative of the word, a futilitarian is one who believes that human striving is futile (“Futile”). Tom’s exaggerated ravings are a good example of futility; he sees work as an imposter in life, keeping him from reaching his full potential. Laziness is self-explanatory: most people would rather be on vacation than working; many are on vacation while working. My parents instilled a strong work ethic in me: consequently, when beginning my first “real” jobs, I was always amazed that my employers were overwhelmed by what I consider “just doing my job.” Evidently, that is the exception, not the norm. Ironically, though most people complain about their jobs, many also swing to the other side of the spectrum and make an idol out of work, becoming workaholics. In The Fabric of This World, Lee Hardy observes:
Few of us can claim that our lives are well-balanced. And in our own culture, work is often the part of our vocation which claims disproportionately large amounts of our time and energy. Especially for those in the professions, the constant temptation is to make an idol of one’s work. Other human relationships, even the relationship to God, must often make way for the high-speed pursuit of a successful career. (114)
Intrinsically, we can also attest that we are created to be workers. The flip side of futility in work is usefulness, or a sense of purpose and meaning. Unfortunately, most people see their jobs as necessary for survival, but lacking in purpose and meaning. A common saying, “Leave work at work” is good advice for most, but the inner cry of these unfulfilled, disillusioned workers echoes that of Norah Watson, who says, “There’s nothing I would enjoy more than a job that was so meaningful that I brought it home” (qtd. in Guinness 37). This desire for meaning is the intrinsic proof that work should mean more than clock in / clock out. Logically, it just doesn’t make sense to spend 97,760 hours, 12,220 days, 33.4 solid years of one’s life in an occupation that exists only to put bread on the table. A sense of meaning is crucial.
Some try to infuse meaning into work by pursuing a vocation. In our culture today, a vocation is typically thought of as a career that has some sort of innate use, purpose, or meaning, such as nursing or counseling. Because these professions minister directly to an aching humanity, they are considered worthwhile, meaningful. However, the same word often means nothing more than one’s job. When asking about someone’s vocation, most people expect an answer telling what the person does for a living. The confusion surrounding this word goes back centuries. Martin Luther, after his “discovery” of justification by faith alone, sought to develop a right concept of the meaning of work in the human life. It was his belief that, just as God ordained man to contribute physically to the upkeep of the planet, “the order of stations (vocations) in the earthly kingdom has been instituted by God himself as his way of seeing that the needs of humanity are met on a day-to-day basis. […] That is, by working we actually participate in God’s ongoing providence for the human race” (Hardy 47).
Our heritage of the Protestant work ethic originally revolved around this concept of serviceability and usefulness in vocation. In her book Ye Heart of a Man, Lisa Wilson notes, “Men [in colonial New England] spoke of their work in terms of serviceableness or usefulness to their community as well as duty to their family. A young man in the seventeenth century focused on his potential for service to God, family, and community” (16). Value was placed in the pursuit of a profession and a life that honored God and served the community. One’s vocation encompassed all facets of life; once that vocation (also referred to as “calling”) was found, “the dogged pursuit of work—diligence—was required” (Wilson 17). The temptation to create an idol out of work existed even then, however; Wilson asserts that “[b]y the end of the eighteenth century, this cultural imperative began to change. Hard work had become a virtue in its own right. Puritans had evolved into Yankees” (15). Throughout the colonial period, the notion of vocation evolved from being God- and community-centered, toward being centered on industry and self-fulfillment (Wilson 22). A major impetus in the evolution of vocation was the rise of industrialization. In her introduction to Louisa May Alcott’s book Work, Joy Kasson remarks that, even though the “injunction to labor diligently in one’s calling had been deeply ingrained in the culture of Puritan New England, […] the post-Civil War industrial boom brought many of the traditional values of the work ethic into question” (xxix). Our confusion surrounding the word “vocation” can be boiled down to linguistic reasons: the word has remained, yet its meaning has evolved; our understanding of the word has not always evolved along with it.
The Puritans did not distinguish between vocation and calling—they were one and the same, encompassing both one’s profession and one’s responsibilities to God, family, and community. In our present culture, the notion of “calling” has been separated from “vocation.” Today, some look for a special “call” to a particular field, thinking that if they are not called to it, they will not be fulfilled by it. Os Guinness warns against anyone who makes “‘vocation’ different from ‘calling’” (48). The terms are synonymous, and I believe that the term “work” should be regarded as a synonym as well. Our work, our vocation, and our calling should be intricately woven together, focused on a common goal. However, as Guinness soberly states, “If there had been no Fall, all our work would have naturally and fully expressed who we are and exercised the gifts we have been given […] Thus to find work that perfectly fits our callings is not a right, but a blessing” (50). Although our work may not always line up with our callings, that should be the ultimate goal, the ideal.
Our confusion about these terms stems from the fact that we have forgotten the source of callings. One cannot be called without a Caller! In responding to the Caller, our lives are not a futile, predetermined clockwork of events, but a dynamic, courageous response to the One who calls “everyone, everywhere, and in everything [to] think, speak, live, and act entirely for him” (Guinness 31). The primary message of this paper is this fact: before we are responsible to something, we are responsible to Someone; before we are called to something, we are called to Someone. Deuteronomy 13:3-4 sums up the twofold aspect of calling very well: “…the LORD your God proveth you, to know whether ye love the LORD your God with all your heat and with all your soul. Ye shall walk after the LORD your God, and fear him, and keep his commandments, and obey his voice, and ye shall serve him, and cleave unto him.” Our primary call is to love God with our entire heart, soul, strength, and mind. Our secondary call is to use the gifts He has given us to serve both Him and others. The downfall of the Puritan theology of vocation was forgetting the Caller and focusing on the call.
Initially, the Puritans did understand the nature of calling. For one to glorify God with a life of usefulness and serviceableness, one must recognize the callings of God upon his or her life. A good basis for this is the recognition of the gifts and talents with which God has equipped us. The most ambitious goals can never be realized if one is not equipped to realize them. William Samuel Johnson of Stratford, Connecticut understood this concept when, in 1747, he concluded, “I must Consider not in what profession the greatest Good May be Done to Mankind, but in what Station I with these Dispositions, these Abilities and Acquirements which I possess are most likely to Serve them” (qtd. in Wilson 19). As we pursue a healthy, vibrant relationship with the Caller and give Him access to those dispositions, abilities, and acquirements given by Him, they will be vehicles to answer His call in our daily lives.
Perhaps one of the best examples of someone who understood the true nature of work and of calling is William Wilberforce. Effecting great change in the political and cultural areas of early 19th century England, Wilberforce first of all and through it all was “animated by a deeply held, personal faith in Jesus Christ” (Pollock 8). “[M]otivated by a robust personal belief in a living God who is concerned with individual human lives, justice, and the transformation of societies” (Pollock 8), Wilberforce determined his God-given gifts and callings and dedicated his life to accomplishing “two great objects, the suppression of the Slave Trade and the reformation of manners” (Pollock 7). Wilberforce understood both to Whom he was responsible and for what he was responsible. This great reformer also understood the benefit of work. He used his work as a Member of Parliament to facilitate the completion of his callings. William Wilberforce exemplified a life of excellence: serving God, serving others, making a difference.
I envy William Wilberforce. His “two great objects” gave him a clear, concrete path on which to direct his focus and energy. Too often, my sense of life goals and callings is so abstract that the light shines only on the spot of ground presently under my feet. There is a balance. In his discussion on calling, Os Guinness is careful to warn against the need for a clear-cut vision. He says, “In many cases a clear sense of calling comes only through a time of searching, including trial and error” (51). Because God is supernatural, there is something inherently supernatural and mysterious about His calling. We often try to sum up our calling succinctly. Like the very nature of God, and of us who are made in His image, our callings are multi-faceted. This goes back to the fact that we are responsible to a Caller, not to a call. I was recently talking about this responsibility with my cousin Judson. The concept clicked instantly with him: he said, “It makes so much sense to focus on the Caller rather than the call. For example, when I call my daughters, I don’t always say the same thing, but they are nevertheless responsible to respond to it.” Our lives are varied and changing. Being grounded in a fervent love for God is a vital foundation, giving security and enabling us to respond to the various tasks and missions that He calls us to. We can be like Abraham and the children of Israel, who “did not always know the way God was leading them, but they always knew why they trusted God: His word was the promise and his call was the way” (Guinness 168). There is comfort in knowing that if we live our lives in response to the Caller, we cannot lose our way; our life will have meaning and purpose before the “Audience of One” (Guinness 70).
There are practical ways to determine what our various callings may be. As mentioned, God gives each of us particular gifts and abilities. Although at times He leads us to suffer for His sake and be involved in a task that is not desirable, for the most part He expects us to use those natural gifts, talents, and desires to serve Him and fulfill our callings. Using the gifts and desires that come naturally to us in service to God and others allows us to “do what we are” (Guinness 47). There is temptation to be selfish in this; that temptation should be tempered by the knowledge that we are only stewards of everything we think we possess. “We are not our own; we have been bought with a price. We have no rights, only responsibilities” (Guinness 167). Stewardship takes center stage in the allegorical morality play Everyman: Everyman must take stock of his “friends” and settle his account with God. With surprise, he discovers that his friend Goods does not intend to accompany him past the grave. Goods poses the question, “What, weenest thou that I am thine?” (line 437). Everyman responds in the affirmative. Goods then remonstrates, “Nay, Everyman, I say no. / As for a while I was lent thee” (lines 439-440). A healthy knowledge and fear of this stewardship of all we think we possess will stave off selfishness and allow our giftedness to be “service that is perfect freedom” (Guinness 47). Once again, the key is to focus on the Caller; He will give the marching orders. Until the clear vision comes, a sure way to fulfill our callings is to live life eucharistically and sacramentally, using all our abilities and gifts to the glory of God.
As Francis Schaeffer says, “How shall we then live?” Until the very last, I have put off the discussion of my own callings. Even after this study, I am still mystified as to how it specifically applies to me. I know the source of part of my confusion: for all of my life I have felt a very strong calling to be a wife and mother. My own mother was married at 18 years of age and gave birth to me the very next year. I expected to follow in her footsteps, and for that reason, never planned to pursue college or career. My greatest passions and joys have been to develop skills and knowledge and virtues that will enable me “to love [my] husband, to love [my] children, to be discreet, chaste, keeper at home, good, obedient to [my] own husband, that the word of God be not blasphemed” (Titus 2:4-5). Well, times have changed since my mother’s day, and God has had other plans for me since high school. I am 27 years old now and, so far, God has not deemed it necessary to introduce me to my husband. It is very frustrating to feel such a strong call and not be able to fulfill it. So, I have had to search and pray for other callings that God has set before me.
The searching aspect has taken very tangible forms. My parents assert that I have inherited my grandfather’s “gypsy blood”. In the ten years since high school, I have lived in Maine, Massachusetts, the Bahamas, and Texas; besides those locations, I have traveled all over New England, to Canada, Florida, New Mexico, and England. My work experience ranges from landscaping to waitressing, bridal consulting to ER staff support, substitute teaching to housekeeping. That is a small sample—in total, I have probably held close to thirty full- or part-time jobs, often two or three at a time. College has worked its way into my life and gypsy blood as well. My major has changed from Bible to liberal arts to nursing to midwifery to biology and, finally, to English. (Hopefully it has settled long enough for me to complete a degree.)
In reflection upon the gifts and talents that God has equipped me with, music immediately comes to mind. Wherever I am, I seek to use my voice and instrumental skills to bless others and serve the Lord. A love for children is another gift that God has blessed me with. Having none of my own is no excuse to hide this talent in the ground. This gift, then, I seek to use by spending time with the children around me, at church and in my family. I love to encourage younger girls by being a faithful pen-pal. I remember how influential some of the older girls in my school were on my young life and I want to be a godly influence to the girls who look up to me. A burden of mine is to serve and support home-schooling moms. Had I more time outside of school, I would spend it with them, helping them in this rewarding but exhausting task. Whatever knowledge I gain, my immediate response is to share it with others. In reflection upon these gifts and talents, I determined that perhaps God is calling me to be a teacher. This, then, is one of my goals right now.
Throughout my wanderings, one thing has become clear: life is way too big and interesting to focus on only one vocation! A quick glance at my schedule in this, my senior year, is a clue into my continuing diverse interests. My classes consist of Russian, English, Readers Theatre, and Digital Photography; I also work in the Writing Center, substitute teach in the Arlington ISD, grade papers for a third grade teacher, and direct one of the children’s choirs at my church. I have attempted to narrow my job fields in order to boost my resume for future teaching positions; however, I would be just as happy to pay rent by waiting tables or selling shoes.
I have learned, especially in the ten years that I have been out of high school, to be flexible with my life goals. The prophet Jeremiah prays, “O Lord, I know that the way of man is not in himself: it is not in man that walketh to direct his steps” (10:23). My course has already changed many times, but I can truly say with J.R.R. Tolkien that “not all who wander are lost.” There is omnipresence in God’s calling. Throughout my journeys, I have never questioned whether or not I should be where I am. The hand of God has been evident every step of the way. I have often questioned why my path has skipped around so much, but I have not regretted any job, any class, any life change. It should not be surprising that my microbiology training helps me in my literature studies and that my midwifery studies bless women in my church. The God who created all things connects all things. He desires that we see His creation as a whole organism, not as segmented compartments of academic disciplines. My varied experiences have not only shaped who I am, but have also given me the delightful assurance that my God has even more diverse interests than I do.
George MacDonald reflects that “the road to the next duty is the only straight one.” If my purpose and meaning in life is always to follow the voice of my Caller in what He tells me to do today, it doesn’t really matter whether or not I have a map. On one hand, part of me still hopes for an epiphany—a clear-cut vision of the life work God would have me accomplish for Him. On the other hand, I know better. I cannot gauge my life by how God appears to work in others, for calling is not only personal, but personalized. And, though we may set goals and have ambitions, calling is primarily present-oriented. A common misconception (especially among the fortunate people who know exactly “what they want to do when they grow up”) is that college is simply one of the steps toward calling. Not so. Right now, college is my work, my vocation, my calling. Oswald Chambers reflects, “We have an idea that God is leading us to a particular end, a desired goal; He is not. […] What men call training and preparation, God calls the end; […] if we realize that obedience is the end, then each moment as it comes is precious” (210). Is that not liberating? My work is to glorify God with full obedience and enthusiasm to His call today, whether that call is to read 400 pages of Moby Dick or to leave a Russian class early in order to present a paper at a symposium. To quote the words of my beloved elementary school teacher who went to be with the Lord last year, “We are prone to think that God’s goal for us is up ahead, when, all the time it’s the present minute He is concerned about. Are we glorifying Him, now? Are we walking worthy today?” Obedience is the call, today and every day.
Works Cited
Chambers, Oswald. My Utmost for His Highest. Uhrichsville, OH: Barbour & Co., 1963.
Everyman. The Norton Anthology of English Literature. Eds. M.H. Abrams and Stephen Greenblatt. 7th ed. Vol. 1. New York: WW Norton & Company, 2000. 446-467.
“Futile.” Merriam Webster’s collegiate Dictionary. 10th ed. 1994.
Guinness, Os. The Call: Finding and Fulfilling the Central Purpose of Your Life. Nashville: W Publishing Group, 2003.
Hardy, Lee. The Fabric Of This World. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1990.
Kasson, Joy. Introduction. Work. By Louisa May Alcott. 1873. New York: Penguin Books, 1994. xxix.
Naugle, David. “Biblical Principles and Purposes of Work.” Class study notes. December 2005.
Pollock, John. William Wilberforce: A Man Who Changed His Times. McLean, Virginia: The Trinity Forum Reading, 1996.
Wilson, Lisa. Ye Heart of a Man. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1999.
***************************************************
What Will I Do When I Grow Up?
Reflections of a DCM Student on the Theology of Work and Vocation
“Calling is the truth that God calls us to himself so decisively that everything we are, everything we do, and everything we have is invested with a special devotion, dynamism, and direction lived out as a response to his summons and service.”
~Os Guinness
Calling is a phenomenon that is greatly over-mystified and obscured during our times. The terms “work”, “vocation”, and “calling” are at best confused and at worst elevated to different levels of importance, ranging from necessary but mundane work, through worthy and respectable vocation, to superior and unarguable calling (that is to say, the person who receives the “call” is allowed to be dogmatic about it, regardless of how it affects those around him or her). The purpose of this paper is to define the terms work, vocation, and calling, illustrate the dynamics between them, and determine through Biblical teachings what my individual callings are.
Of the three terms, work is the easiest to define. Work is what we do when we are not at leisure. For most people, work is considered a necessary evil, and the majority of people in the work force do not enjoy what they do for a living. This is unfortunate, as well as faulty thinking and practice, for God created us as workers. This can be verified both Biblically and intrinsically.
Biblically, we cannot escape the fact that God (a worker Himself) has passed this standard to the created Adamic race. The Garden of Eden would not be considered the ultimate vacation destination by today’s standards, for Adam and Eve were designed for and commanded to work. The first commandment given to man, also referred to as the “creation mandate,” is found in Genesis 1:28: “And God blessed them, and God said unto them, Be fruitful, and multiply, and replenish the earth, and subdue it: and have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the fowl of the air, and over every living thing that moveth upon the earth.” This command is tri-fold: to populate the earth, to cultivate the earth, and to be a steward of the earth. The cultivation and stewardship aspects of the command continue in Genesis 2:15: “And the LORD God took the man, and put him into the garden of Eden to dress it and to keep it.” There is little room for ambiguity here: God physically set the man and woman into their life work. From this elevated starting point, somehow the concept of work has descended into one of drudgery and meaninglessness. Even though most people are not happy in their jobs, they would be equally unhappy in a life of complete leisure because we have an inner, God-given drive to work. There the paradox lies: it is not that people are not meant to work, but that “[j]obs are not big enough for people” (qtd. in Guinness 36). If the lives surrounding us are not enough to convince us of this, literature is full of examples of the frustrated workforce. For instance, in Tennessee Williams’ play The Glass Menagerie, Tom raves, “Look! I’d rather somebody picked up a crowbar and battered out my brains—than go back mornings! I go! […] I say to myself, ‘How lucky dead people are!’ But I get up. I go! For sixty-five dollars a month I give up all that I dream of doing and being ever!” (453). Is work really such a curse? What is the answer to this seeming paradox?
Work was an intentional part of God’s good creation, but like every other good thing created by God, work has been cursed as a result of the Fall of man. As lies are but a twisting of the truth, all sin is but a twisting or distortion, a reversal of devotion, of something that God initially intended for good. The distortion of work has brought into it the treacherous trio of futility, laziness, and idolatry (Naugle 2). Futility is the state of serving no useful purpose, according to Webster’s dictionary. As a derivative of the word, a futilitarian is one who believes that human striving is futile (“Futile”). Tom’s exaggerated ravings are a good example of futility; he sees work as an imposter in life, keeping him from reaching his full potential. Laziness is self-explanatory: most people would rather be on vacation than working; many are on vacation while working. My parents instilled a strong work ethic in me: consequently, when beginning my first “real” jobs, I was always amazed that my employers were overwhelmed by what I consider “just doing my job.” Evidently, that is the exception, not the norm. Ironically, though most people complain about their jobs, many also swing to the other side of the spectrum and make an idol out of work, becoming workaholics. In The Fabric of This World, Lee Hardy observes:
Few of us can claim that our lives are well-balanced. And in our own culture, work is often the part of our vocation which claims disproportionately large amounts of our time and energy. Especially for those in the professions, the constant temptation is to make an idol of one’s work. Other human relationships, even the relationship to God, must often make way for the high-speed pursuit of a successful career. (114)
Intrinsically, we can also attest that we are created to be workers. The flip side of futility in work is usefulness, or a sense of purpose and meaning. Unfortunately, most people see their jobs as necessary for survival, but lacking in purpose and meaning. A common saying, “Leave work at work” is good advice for most, but the inner cry of these unfulfilled, disillusioned workers echoes that of Norah Watson, who says, “There’s nothing I would enjoy more than a job that was so meaningful that I brought it home” (qtd. in Guinness 37). This desire for meaning is the intrinsic proof that work should mean more than clock in / clock out. Logically, it just doesn’t make sense to spend 97,760 hours, 12,220 days, 33.4 solid years of one’s life in an occupation that exists only to put bread on the table. A sense of meaning is crucial.
Some try to infuse meaning into work by pursuing a vocation. In our culture today, a vocation is typically thought of as a career that has some sort of innate use, purpose, or meaning, such as nursing or counseling. Because these professions minister directly to an aching humanity, they are considered worthwhile, meaningful. However, the same word often means nothing more than one’s job. When asking about someone’s vocation, most people expect an answer telling what the person does for a living. The confusion surrounding this word goes back centuries. Martin Luther, after his “discovery” of justification by faith alone, sought to develop a right concept of the meaning of work in the human life. It was his belief that, just as God ordained man to contribute physically to the upkeep of the planet, “the order of stations (vocations) in the earthly kingdom has been instituted by God himself as his way of seeing that the needs of humanity are met on a day-to-day basis. […] That is, by working we actually participate in God’s ongoing providence for the human race” (Hardy 47).
Our heritage of the Protestant work ethic originally revolved around this concept of serviceability and usefulness in vocation. In her book Ye Heart of a Man, Lisa Wilson notes, “Men [in colonial New England] spoke of their work in terms of serviceableness or usefulness to their community as well as duty to their family. A young man in the seventeenth century focused on his potential for service to God, family, and community” (16). Value was placed in the pursuit of a profession and a life that honored God and served the community. One’s vocation encompassed all facets of life; once that vocation (also referred to as “calling”) was found, “the dogged pursuit of work—diligence—was required” (Wilson 17). The temptation to create an idol out of work existed even then, however; Wilson asserts that “[b]y the end of the eighteenth century, this cultural imperative began to change. Hard work had become a virtue in its own right. Puritans had evolved into Yankees” (15). Throughout the colonial period, the notion of vocation evolved from being God- and community-centered, toward being centered on industry and self-fulfillment (Wilson 22). A major impetus in the evolution of vocation was the rise of industrialization. In her introduction to Louisa May Alcott’s book Work, Joy Kasson remarks that, even though the “injunction to labor diligently in one’s calling had been deeply ingrained in the culture of Puritan New England, […] the post-Civil War industrial boom brought many of the traditional values of the work ethic into question” (xxix). Our confusion surrounding the word “vocation” can be boiled down to linguistic reasons: the word has remained, yet its meaning has evolved; our understanding of the word has not always evolved along with it.
The Puritans did not distinguish between vocation and calling—they were one and the same, encompassing both one’s profession and one’s responsibilities to God, family, and community. In our present culture, the notion of “calling” has been separated from “vocation.” Today, some look for a special “call” to a particular field, thinking that if they are not called to it, they will not be fulfilled by it. Os Guinness warns against anyone who makes “‘vocation’ different from ‘calling’” (48). The terms are synonymous, and I believe that the term “work” should be regarded as a synonym as well. Our work, our vocation, and our calling should be intricately woven together, focused on a common goal. However, as Guinness soberly states, “If there had been no Fall, all our work would have naturally and fully expressed who we are and exercised the gifts we have been given […] Thus to find work that perfectly fits our callings is not a right, but a blessing” (50). Although our work may not always line up with our callings, that should be the ultimate goal, the ideal.
Our confusion about these terms stems from the fact that we have forgotten the source of callings. One cannot be called without a Caller! In responding to the Caller, our lives are not a futile, predetermined clockwork of events, but a dynamic, courageous response to the One who calls “everyone, everywhere, and in everything [to] think, speak, live, and act entirely for him” (Guinness 31). The primary message of this paper is this fact: before we are responsible to something, we are responsible to Someone; before we are called to something, we are called to Someone. Deuteronomy 13:3-4 sums up the twofold aspect of calling very well: “…the LORD your God proveth you, to know whether ye love the LORD your God with all your heat and with all your soul. Ye shall walk after the LORD your God, and fear him, and keep his commandments, and obey his voice, and ye shall serve him, and cleave unto him.” Our primary call is to love God with our entire heart, soul, strength, and mind. Our secondary call is to use the gifts He has given us to serve both Him and others. The downfall of the Puritan theology of vocation was forgetting the Caller and focusing on the call.
Initially, the Puritans did understand the nature of calling. For one to glorify God with a life of usefulness and serviceableness, one must recognize the callings of God upon his or her life. A good basis for this is the recognition of the gifts and talents with which God has equipped us. The most ambitious goals can never be realized if one is not equipped to realize them. William Samuel Johnson of Stratford, Connecticut understood this concept when, in 1747, he concluded, “I must Consider not in what profession the greatest Good May be Done to Mankind, but in what Station I with these Dispositions, these Abilities and Acquirements which I possess are most likely to Serve them” (qtd. in Wilson 19). As we pursue a healthy, vibrant relationship with the Caller and give Him access to those dispositions, abilities, and acquirements given by Him, they will be vehicles to answer His call in our daily lives.
Perhaps one of the best examples of someone who understood the true nature of work and of calling is William Wilberforce. Effecting great change in the political and cultural areas of early 19th century England, Wilberforce first of all and through it all was “animated by a deeply held, personal faith in Jesus Christ” (Pollock 8). “[M]otivated by a robust personal belief in a living God who is concerned with individual human lives, justice, and the transformation of societies” (Pollock 8), Wilberforce determined his God-given gifts and callings and dedicated his life to accomplishing “two great objects, the suppression of the Slave Trade and the reformation of manners” (Pollock 7). Wilberforce understood both to Whom he was responsible and for what he was responsible. This great reformer also understood the benefit of work. He used his work as a Member of Parliament to facilitate the completion of his callings. William Wilberforce exemplified a life of excellence: serving God, serving others, making a difference.
I envy William Wilberforce. His “two great objects” gave him a clear, concrete path on which to direct his focus and energy. Too often, my sense of life goals and callings is so abstract that the light shines only on the spot of ground presently under my feet. There is a balance. In his discussion on calling, Os Guinness is careful to warn against the need for a clear-cut vision. He says, “In many cases a clear sense of calling comes only through a time of searching, including trial and error” (51). Because God is supernatural, there is something inherently supernatural and mysterious about His calling. We often try to sum up our calling succinctly. Like the very nature of God, and of us who are made in His image, our callings are multi-faceted. This goes back to the fact that we are responsible to a Caller, not to a call. I was recently talking about this responsibility with my cousin Judson. The concept clicked instantly with him: he said, “It makes so much sense to focus on the Caller rather than the call. For example, when I call my daughters, I don’t always say the same thing, but they are nevertheless responsible to respond to it.” Our lives are varied and changing. Being grounded in a fervent love for God is a vital foundation, giving security and enabling us to respond to the various tasks and missions that He calls us to. We can be like Abraham and the children of Israel, who “did not always know the way God was leading them, but they always knew why they trusted God: His word was the promise and his call was the way” (Guinness 168). There is comfort in knowing that if we live our lives in response to the Caller, we cannot lose our way; our life will have meaning and purpose before the “Audience of One” (Guinness 70).
There are practical ways to determine what our various callings may be. As mentioned, God gives each of us particular gifts and abilities. Although at times He leads us to suffer for His sake and be involved in a task that is not desirable, for the most part He expects us to use those natural gifts, talents, and desires to serve Him and fulfill our callings. Using the gifts and desires that come naturally to us in service to God and others allows us to “do what we are” (Guinness 47). There is temptation to be selfish in this; that temptation should be tempered by the knowledge that we are only stewards of everything we think we possess. “We are not our own; we have been bought with a price. We have no rights, only responsibilities” (Guinness 167). Stewardship takes center stage in the allegorical morality play Everyman: Everyman must take stock of his “friends” and settle his account with God. With surprise, he discovers that his friend Goods does not intend to accompany him past the grave. Goods poses the question, “What, weenest thou that I am thine?” (line 437). Everyman responds in the affirmative. Goods then remonstrates, “Nay, Everyman, I say no. / As for a while I was lent thee” (lines 439-440). A healthy knowledge and fear of this stewardship of all we think we possess will stave off selfishness and allow our giftedness to be “service that is perfect freedom” (Guinness 47). Once again, the key is to focus on the Caller; He will give the marching orders. Until the clear vision comes, a sure way to fulfill our callings is to live life eucharistically and sacramentally, using all our abilities and gifts to the glory of God.
As Francis Schaeffer says, “How shall we then live?” Until the very last, I have put off the discussion of my own callings. Even after this study, I am still mystified as to how it specifically applies to me. I know the source of part of my confusion: for all of my life I have felt a very strong calling to be a wife and mother. My own mother was married at 18 years of age and gave birth to me the very next year. I expected to follow in her footsteps, and for that reason, never planned to pursue college or career. My greatest passions and joys have been to develop skills and knowledge and virtues that will enable me “to love [my] husband, to love [my] children, to be discreet, chaste, keeper at home, good, obedient to [my] own husband, that the word of God be not blasphemed” (Titus 2:4-5). Well, times have changed since my mother’s day, and God has had other plans for me since high school. I am 27 years old now and, so far, God has not deemed it necessary to introduce me to my husband. It is very frustrating to feel such a strong call and not be able to fulfill it. So, I have had to search and pray for other callings that God has set before me.
The searching aspect has taken very tangible forms. My parents assert that I have inherited my grandfather’s “gypsy blood”. In the ten years since high school, I have lived in Maine, Massachusetts, the Bahamas, and Texas; besides those locations, I have traveled all over New England, to Canada, Florida, New Mexico, and England. My work experience ranges from landscaping to waitressing, bridal consulting to ER staff support, substitute teaching to housekeeping. That is a small sample—in total, I have probably held close to thirty full- or part-time jobs, often two or three at a time. College has worked its way into my life and gypsy blood as well. My major has changed from Bible to liberal arts to nursing to midwifery to biology and, finally, to English. (Hopefully it has settled long enough for me to complete a degree.)
In reflection upon the gifts and talents that God has equipped me with, music immediately comes to mind. Wherever I am, I seek to use my voice and instrumental skills to bless others and serve the Lord. A love for children is another gift that God has blessed me with. Having none of my own is no excuse to hide this talent in the ground. This gift, then, I seek to use by spending time with the children around me, at church and in my family. I love to encourage younger girls by being a faithful pen-pal. I remember how influential some of the older girls in my school were on my young life and I want to be a godly influence to the girls who look up to me. A burden of mine is to serve and support home-schooling moms. Had I more time outside of school, I would spend it with them, helping them in this rewarding but exhausting task. Whatever knowledge I gain, my immediate response is to share it with others. In reflection upon these gifts and talents, I determined that perhaps God is calling me to be a teacher. This, then, is one of my goals right now.
Throughout my wanderings, one thing has become clear: life is way too big and interesting to focus on only one vocation! A quick glance at my schedule in this, my senior year, is a clue into my continuing diverse interests. My classes consist of Russian, English, Readers Theatre, and Digital Photography; I also work in the Writing Center, substitute teach in the Arlington ISD, grade papers for a third grade teacher, and direct one of the children’s choirs at my church. I have attempted to narrow my job fields in order to boost my resume for future teaching positions; however, I would be just as happy to pay rent by waiting tables or selling shoes.
I have learned, especially in the ten years that I have been out of high school, to be flexible with my life goals. The prophet Jeremiah prays, “O Lord, I know that the way of man is not in himself: it is not in man that walketh to direct his steps” (10:23). My course has already changed many times, but I can truly say with J.R.R. Tolkien that “not all who wander are lost.” There is omnipresence in God’s calling. Throughout my journeys, I have never questioned whether or not I should be where I am. The hand of God has been evident every step of the way. I have often questioned why my path has skipped around so much, but I have not regretted any job, any class, any life change. It should not be surprising that my microbiology training helps me in my literature studies and that my midwifery studies bless women in my church. The God who created all things connects all things. He desires that we see His creation as a whole organism, not as segmented compartments of academic disciplines. My varied experiences have not only shaped who I am, but have also given me the delightful assurance that my God has even more diverse interests than I do.
George MacDonald reflects that “the road to the next duty is the only straight one.” If my purpose and meaning in life is always to follow the voice of my Caller in what He tells me to do today, it doesn’t really matter whether or not I have a map. On one hand, part of me still hopes for an epiphany—a clear-cut vision of the life work God would have me accomplish for Him. On the other hand, I know better. I cannot gauge my life by how God appears to work in others, for calling is not only personal, but personalized. And, though we may set goals and have ambitions, calling is primarily present-oriented. A common misconception (especially among the fortunate people who know exactly “what they want to do when they grow up”) is that college is simply one of the steps toward calling. Not so. Right now, college is my work, my vocation, my calling. Oswald Chambers reflects, “We have an idea that God is leading us to a particular end, a desired goal; He is not. […] What men call training and preparation, God calls the end; […] if we realize that obedience is the end, then each moment as it comes is precious” (210). Is that not liberating? My work is to glorify God with full obedience and enthusiasm to His call today, whether that call is to read 400 pages of Moby Dick or to leave a Russian class early in order to present a paper at a symposium. To quote the words of my beloved elementary school teacher who went to be with the Lord last year, “We are prone to think that God’s goal for us is up ahead, when, all the time it’s the present minute He is concerned about. Are we glorifying Him, now? Are we walking worthy today?” Obedience is the call, today and every day.
Works Cited
Chambers, Oswald. My Utmost for His Highest. Uhrichsville, OH: Barbour & Co., 1963.
Everyman. The Norton Anthology of English Literature. Eds. M.H. Abrams and Stephen Greenblatt. 7th ed. Vol. 1. New York: WW Norton & Company, 2000. 446-467.
“Futile.” Merriam Webster’s collegiate Dictionary. 10th ed. 1994.
Guinness, Os. The Call: Finding and Fulfilling the Central Purpose of Your Life. Nashville: W Publishing Group, 2003.
Hardy, Lee. The Fabric Of This World. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1990.
Kasson, Joy. Introduction. Work. By Louisa May Alcott. 1873. New York: Penguin Books, 1994. xxix.
Naugle, David. “Biblical Principles and Purposes of Work.” Class study notes. December 2005.
Pollock, John. William Wilberforce: A Man Who Changed His Times. McLean, Virginia: The Trinity Forum Reading, 1996.
Wilson, Lisa. Ye Heart of a Man. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1999.


1 Comments:
Very nice! I love how you compare and contrast the idea of work, vocation and calling. When our greatest concern is God's best interest, they all support each other. It's great that you looked at Historical and Biblical events as foundations.
As you mentioned, there is a God given drive to work, and without work, we would be equally unhappy. God's very nature is hard working (thinking of creation). I love how we can go back to the beginning (Genesis) for answers!
I'd love to read more of what you write in the future. Keep it up! :)
-K
Post a Comment
<< Home